United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit

The United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit (in case citations, D.C. Cir.) is one of the thirteen United States Courts of Appeals. It has the smallest geographical jurisdiction of any of the U.S. federal appellate courts, and covers only one district court: the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. It meets at the E. Barrett Prettyman United States Courthouse, near Judiciary Square, Washington, D.C.

The D.C. Circuit's prominence and prestige among American courts is second only to the U.S. Supreme Court because its jurisdiction contains the U.S. Congress and many U.S. government agencies, and therefore it is the main appellate court for many issues of American administrative law and constitutional law. Four of the current nine justices on the Supreme Court were previously judges on the D.C. Circuit: Associate Justices Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas, Ruth Badger Ginsburg, and Karen Henderson. Former justices Fred M. Vinson, Wiley Blount Rutledge, and Warren E. Burger also served as judges on the D.C. Circuit before their appointments to the Supreme Court.

Because the D.C. Circuit does not represent any state, confirmation of nominees can be procedurally and practically easier than for nominees to the Courts of Appeals for the other geographical districts, as home-state senators have historically been able to hold up confirmation through the "blue slip" process.

List of former judges
{| class="wikitable" style="width:100%;text-align:left;font-size:75%" !# !Judge !State !Born–died !Term of service !Appointed by !Reason for termination
 * rowspan="1" |1
 * rowspan="1" |Richard Henry Alvey
 * rowspan="1" |MD
 * rowspan="1" |1826–1906
 * rowspan="1" |1893–1905 (active) 1893–1905 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Cleveland
 * rowspan="1" |Retirement
 * rowspan="1" |2
 * rowspan="1" |Martin Ferdinand Morris
 * rowspan="1" |DC
 * rowspan="1" |1834–1909
 * rowspan="1" |1893–1905 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Cleveland
 * rowspan="1" |Retirement
 * rowspan="1" |3
 * rowspan="1" |Seth Shepard
 * rowspan="1" |TX
 * rowspan="1" |1847–1917
 * rowspan="1" |1893–1917 (active) 1905–1917 (chief)
 * rowspan="1" |Cleveland (associate) T. Roosevelt (chief)
 * rowspan="1" |Retirement
 * rowspan="1" |4
 * rowspan="1" |Charles Holland Duell
 * rowspan="1" |NY
 * rowspan="1" |1950–1920
 * rowspan="1" |1905–1906 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |T. Roosevelt
 * rowspan="1" |Resignation
 * rowspan="1" |5
 * rowspan="1" |Louis E. McComas
 * rowspan="1" |MD
 * rowspan="1" |1846–1907
 * rowspan="1" |1905–1907 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |T. Roosevelt
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |6
 * rowspan="1" |Charles Henry Robb
 * rowspan="1" |VT
 * rowspan="1" |1867–1939
 * rowspan="1" |1906–1937 (active) 1937–1949 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |T. Roosevelt
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |7
 * rowspan="1" |Josiah Alexander Van Orsdel
 * rowspan="1" |WY
 * rowspan="1" |1860–1937
 * rowspan="1" |1907–1937 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |T. Roosevelt
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |8
 * rowspan="1" |Constantine Joseph Smyth
 * rowspan="1" |NE
 * rowspan="1" |1859–1924
 * rowspan="1" |1917–1924 (active) 1917–1924 (chief)
 * rowspan="1" |Wilson
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |9
 * rowspan="1" |George Ewing Martin
 * rowspan="1" |OH
 * rowspan="1" |1857–1948
 * rowspan="1" |1924–1937 (active) 1924–1937 (chief) 1937–1948 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Coolidge
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |10
 * rowspan="1" |William Hitz
 * rowspan="1" |DC
 * rowspan="1" |1872–1935
 * rowspan="1" |1931–1935 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Hoover
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |11
 * rowspan="1" |Duncan Lawrence Groner
 * rowspan="1" |VA
 * rowspan="1" |1873–1957
 * rowspan="1" |1931–1948 (active) 1937–1948 (chief) 1948–1957 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Hoover (associate) F. Roosevelt (chief)
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |12
 * rowspan="1" |Harold Montelle Stephens
 * rowspan="1" |UT
 * rowspan="1" |1886–1955
 * rowspan="1" |1935–1955 (active) 1948–1955 (chief)
 * rowspan="1" |F. Roosevelt (associate) Truman (chief)
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |13
 * rowspan="1" |Justin Miller
 * rowspan="1" |CA
 * rowspan="1" |1888–1973
 * rowspan="1" |1937–1945 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |F. Roosevelt
 * rowspan="1" |Resignation
 * rowspan="1" |14
 * rowspan="1" |Henry White Edgerton
 * rowspan="1" |DC
 * rowspan="1" |1888–1970
 * rowspan="1" |1937–1963 (active) 1955–1958 (chief) 1963–1970 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |F. Roosevelt
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |15
 * rowspan="1" |Fred M. Vinson
 * rowspan="1" |KY
 * rowspan="1" |1890–1953
 * rowspan="1" |1938–1943 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |F. Roosevelt
 * rowspan="1" |Resignation
 * rowspan="1" |16
 * rowspan="1" |Wiley Blount Rutledge
 * rowspan="1" |KY
 * rowspan="1" |1894–1949
 * rowspan="1" |1939–1943 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |F. Roosevelt
 * rowspan="1" |Elevation to Supreme Court
 * rowspan="1" |17
 * rowspan="1" |Thurman Arnold
 * rowspan="1" |WY
 * rowspan="1" |1891–1969
 * rowspan="1" |1943–1945 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |F. Roosevelt
 * rowspan="1" |Resignation
 * rowspan="1" |18
 * rowspan="1" |Bennett Champ Clark
 * rowspan="1" |MO
 * rowspan="1" |1890–1954
 * rowspan="1" |1945–1954 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Truman
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |19
 * rowspan="1" |E. Barrett Prettyman
 * rowspan="1" |DC
 * rowspan="1" |1891–1971
 * rowspan="1" |1945–1962 (active) 1958–1960 (chief) 1962–1971 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Truman
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |20
 * rowspan="1" |Wilbur Kingsbury Miller
 * rowspan="1" |KY
 * rowspan="1" |1892–1976
 * rowspan="1" |1945–1964 (active) 1960–1962 (chief) 1964–1976 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Truman
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |21
 * rowspan="1" |James McPherson Proctor
 * rowspan="1" |DC
 * rowspan="1" |1882–1953
 * rowspan="1" |1948–1953 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Truman
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |22
 * rowspan="1" |David L. Bazelon
 * rowspan="1" |IL
 * rowspan="1" |1909–1993
 * rowspan="1" |1949–1979 (active) 1962–1978 (chief) 1979–1993 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Truman
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |23
 * rowspan="1" |Charles Fahy
 * rowspan="1" |GA
 * rowspan="1" |1892–1979
 * rowspan="1" |1949–1967 (active) 1967–1979 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Truman
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |24
 * rowspan="1" |George Thomas Washington
 * rowspan="1" |OH
 * rowspan="1" |1908–1971
 * rowspan="1" |1949–1965 (active) 1965–1971 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Truman
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |25
 * rowspan="1" |John A. Danaher
 * rowspan="1" |CT
 * rowspan="1" |1899–1990
 * rowspan="1" |1953–1969 (active) 1969–1990 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Eisenhower
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |26
 * rowspan="1" |Walter Maximillian Bastian
 * rowspan="1" |DC
 * rowspan="1" |1891–1975
 * rowspan="1" |1954–1965 (active) 1965–1975 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Eisenhower
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |27
 * rowspan="1" |Warren E. Burger
 * rowspan="1" |MN
 * rowspan="1" |1907–1995
 * rowspan="1" |1956–1969 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Eisenhower
 * rowspan="1" |Elevation to Supreme Court
 * rowspan="1" |28
 * rowspan="1" |James Skelly Wright
 * rowspan="1" |LA
 * rowspan="1" |1911–1988
 * rowspan="1" |1962–1986 (active) 1978–1981 (chief) 1986–1988 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Kennedy
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |29
 * rowspan="1" |Carl E. McGowan
 * rowspan="1" |IL
 * rowspan="1" |1911–1987
 * rowspan="1" |1963–1981 (active) 1981–1981 (chief) 1981–1987 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Kennedy
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |30
 * rowspan="1" |Edward Allen Tamm
 * rowspan="1" |DC
 * rowspan="1" |1906–1985
 * rowspan="1" |1965–1985 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |L. Johnson
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |31
 * rowspan="1" |Harold Leventhal
 * rowspan="1" |DC
 * rowspan="1" |1915–1979
 * rowspan="1" |1965–1979 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |L. Johnson
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |32
 * rowspan="1" |Spottswood W. Robinson III
 * rowspan="1" |VA
 * rowspan="1" |1916–1998
 * rowspan="1" |1966–1989 (active) 1981–1986 (chief) 1989–1998 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |L. Johnson
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |33
 * rowspan="1" |George MacKinnon
 * rowspan="1" |MN
 * rowspan="1" |1906–1995
 * rowspan="1" |1969–1983 (active) 1983–1995 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Nixon
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |34
 * rowspan="1" |Roger Robb
 * rowspan="1" |DC
 * rowspan="1" |1907–1985
 * rowspan="1" |1969–1982 (active) 1982–1985 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Nixon
 * rowspan="1" |Death
 * rowspan="1" |35
 * rowspan="1" |Malcolm Richard Wilkey
 * rowspan="1" |TX
 * rowspan="1" |1918–2009
 * rowspan="1" |1970–1984 (active) 1984–1985 (senior)
 * rowspan="1" |Nixon
 * rowspan="1" |Retirement
 * rowspan="1" |36
 * rowspan="1" |Patricia Wald
 * rowspan="1" |DC
 * rowspan="1" |1928–present
 * rowspan="1" |1979–1999 (active) 1986–1991 (chief)
 * rowspan="1" |Carter
 * rowspan="1" |Retirement
 * rowspan="1" |37
 * rowspan="1" |Abner Mikva
 * rowspan="1" |IL
 * rowspan="1" |1926–present
 * rowspan="1" |1979–1994 (active) 1991–1994 (chief)
 * rowspan="1" |Carter
 * rowspan="1" |Resignation
 * rowspan="1" |39
 * rowspan="1" |Ruth Bader Ginsburg
 * rowspan="1" |NY
 * rowspan="1" |1933–present
 * rowspan="1" |1980–1993 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Carter
 * rowspan="1" |Elevation to Supreme Court
 * rowspan="1" |40
 * rowspan="1" |Robert Bork
 * rowspan="1" |CT
 * rowspan="1" |1927–present
 * rowspan="1" |1982–1988 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Reagan
 * rowspan="1" |Resignation
 * rowspan="1" |41
 * rowspan="1" |Antonin Scalia
 * rowspan="1" |IL
 * rowspan="1" |1936–present
 * rowspan="1" |1982–1986 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Reagan
 * rowspan="1" |Elevation to Supreme Court
 * rowspan="1" |42
 * rowspan="1" |Kenneth Starr
 * rowspan="1" |VA
 * rowspan="1" |1946–present
 * rowspan="1" |1983–1989 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Reagan
 * rowspan="1" |Resignation
 * rowspan="1" |48
 * rowspan="1" |Clarence Thomas
 * rowspan="1" |GA
 * rowspan="1" |1948–present
 * rowspan="1" |1990–1991 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Bush
 * rowspan="1" |Elevation to Supreme Court
 * -|}
 * rowspan="1" |Resignation
 * rowspan="1" |39
 * rowspan="1" |Ruth Bader Ginsburg
 * rowspan="1" |NY
 * rowspan="1" |1933–present
 * rowspan="1" |1980–1993 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Carter
 * rowspan="1" |Elevation to Supreme Court
 * rowspan="1" |40
 * rowspan="1" |Robert Bork
 * rowspan="1" |CT
 * rowspan="1" |1927–present
 * rowspan="1" |1982–1988 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Reagan
 * rowspan="1" |Resignation
 * rowspan="1" |41
 * rowspan="1" |Antonin Scalia
 * rowspan="1" |IL
 * rowspan="1" |1936–present
 * rowspan="1" |1982–1986 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Reagan
 * rowspan="1" |Elevation to Supreme Court
 * rowspan="1" |42
 * rowspan="1" |Kenneth Starr
 * rowspan="1" |VA
 * rowspan="1" |1946–present
 * rowspan="1" |1983–1989 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Reagan
 * rowspan="1" |Resignation
 * rowspan="1" |48
 * rowspan="1" |Clarence Thomas
 * rowspan="1" |GA
 * rowspan="1" |1948–present
 * rowspan="1" |1990–1991 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Bush
 * rowspan="1" |Elevation to Supreme Court
 * -|}
 * rowspan="1" |1948–present
 * rowspan="1" |1990–1991 (active)
 * rowspan="1" |Bush
 * rowspan="1" |Elevation to Supreme Court
 * -|}
 * -|}

Chiefs
When Congress established this court in 1893 as the Court of Appeals of the District of Columbia, it had a Chief Justice, and the other judges were called Associate Justices, which was similar to the structure of the Supreme Court. The Chief Justiceship was a separate seat: the President would appoint the Chief Justice, and that person would stay Chief Justice until he left the court.

On June 25, 1948, 62 Stat. 869 and 62 Stat. 985 became law. These acts made the Chief Justice a Chief Judge. In 1954, another law, 68 Stat. 1245, clarified what was implicit in those laws: that the Chief Judgeship was not a mere renaming of the position but a change in its status that made it the same as the Chief Judge of other inferior courts.

Chief judges have administrative responsibilities with respect to their circuits, and preside over any panel on which they serve unless the circuit justice (i.e., the Supreme Court justice responsible for the circuit) is also on the panel. Unlike the Supreme Court, where one justice is specifically nominated to be chief, the office of chief judge rotates among the circuit judges. To be chief, a judge must have been in active service on the court for at least one year, be under the age of 65, and have not previously served as chief judge. A vacancy is filled by the judge highest in seniority among the group of qualified judges. The chief judge serves for a term of seven years or until age 70, whichever occurs first. The age restrictions are waived if no members of the court would otherwise be qualified for the position.

When the office was created in 1948, the chief judge was the longest-serving judge who had not elected to retire on what has since 1958 been known as senior status or declined to serve as chief judge. After August 6, 1959, judges could not become or remain chief after turning 70 years old. The current rules have been in operation since October 1, 1982.

Succession of seats
The court has twelve seats for active judges. The seat that was originally the Chief Justiceship was numbered as Seat 1; the other seats are numbered in order of their creation. If seats were established simultaneously, they are numbered in the order in which they were filled. Judges who retire into senior status remain on the bench but leave their seat vacant. That seat is filled by the next circuit judge appointed by the President.
 * }